Cement Board Siding Vs Vinyl Siding

Curious as to which wins the battle of lp smartside vs hardie.

Cement board siding vs vinyl siding.

Fiber cement planks are formed by combining wood pulp with portland cement. Compare that to the 8 9 score that vinyl siding received and it is very clear that homeowners love their fiber cement siding more than homeowners who went with vinyl siding. Fiber cement siding carries a certain premium in terms of costs versus vinyl. Again you can provide foam sheathing or insulation to add even greater thickness to the back.

In all areas except for cost hardieplank brand and other high quality fiber cement siding boards are the clear winners over vinyl siding. A typical mid range fiber cement siding installation costs just a tad over 17 000 to 30 000 with a recouped value of about 78 to 80. Overall value for those of you keeping score at home according to the factors we listed vinyl would win in a landslide as the final score is 6 factors favor vinyl 2 favor fiber cement and a tie on one other factor. Are you familiar with this topic.

Up here cement board siding is about 12 000 more expensive to install than vinyl but way more worth it. Vinyl siding however edges out its heavier cousin because fiber cement has been known to absorb. It s around 0 2 inch thick whereas vinyl siding is only 0 040 inches in dimension. When you are trying to decide between a fiber cement board such as hardieplank as opposed to the more cost effective alternative of vinyl siding the answer would be easy if all factors were equal.

Installation of vinyl runs from 3 to 7 for each square foot while fiber cement siding installation is two to three dollars more per square foot. Because of its weight fiber cement siding ends up costing more than vinyl. Fiber cement board is heavy and difficult to cut. Special saw blades are required nails must be predrilled and installation generally takes longer than vinyl.

Vinyl siding vinyl siding is an immensely popular choice as well. Compared with wood both vinyl siding and fiber cement are very durable exterior cladding options. Fiber cement siding is often called hardiplank or even hardie board named from the most popular brand of fiber cement siding which is manufactured by james hardie. This is partly because the heavier boards cost more to transport hence more shipping costs.

These days 3 of the most commonly used siding materials include james hardie fiber cement siding lp smartside engineered wood siding and insulated vinyl siding. The cost to have fiber cement siding installed by a professional ranges from 5 to 10 per sq.